• Home
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Contact
Lake Legal News
  • Home
  • News
  • Favorite Topics
    • An LLN Interview
    • Publisher’s Personal Favorites
    • Odds & Ends
    • Of Interest to Lawyers
    • Civil & Criminal
    • From Our Archives
    • Of Interest to LLN
    • Humor’s Last Stand
    • Guest Author
    • Book Review
  • Online Only!
  • Read Our Magazines
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Favorite Topics
    • An LLN Interview
    • Publisher’s Personal Favorites
    • Odds & Ends
    • Of Interest to Lawyers
    • Civil & Criminal
    • From Our Archives
    • Of Interest to LLN
    • Humor’s Last Stand
    • Guest Author
    • Book Review
  • Online Only!
  • Read Our Magazines
No Result
View All Result
Lake Legal News
No Result
View All Result
Home From Our Archives

REMEMBERING WHEN HE FOUGHT THE “SUPREME” BATTLE

by James Hope, J.D., Publisher & Executive Editor
October 8, 2019 12:21 am
in From Our Archives
96
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare by Email
[PHOTO CREDIT: Courthouses.com]

(This Article was First Published in LLN in May, 2017 — Issue No. 30.)

There are those times in life when it seems necessary to take up a cause, simply because something just doesn’t seem fair. Moreover, depending on the circumstances, fighting-the-good-fight may be a solo pursuit, or it may involve the joint interests of others. And so it came to be, back in the early 1990s, that Dr. James F. Coy — a physician currently practicing in Lake County, Florida — found himself leading-the-charge for justice in a battle which eventually made its way to the Florida Supreme Court, in Tallahassee.

As as part of medical malpractice reforms enacted in Florida in 1988, an entity known as the Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Plan (the “Plan”) was created. As succinctly noted by the Florida Supreme Court in the case of James F. Coy, M.D., et al., v. Florida Birth-related Neurological Injury Compensation Plan, et. al., 595 So.2d 943 (Fla. 1992): 

Several physicians practicing in areas other than obstetrics filed this action… Essentially, the Plan administers a no-fault system to insure against certain types of neurological injuries suffered by infants at birth. However… the statute imposes on all licensed physicians, not merely obstetricians, a mandatory annual assessment of $250. [Emphasis added.]

* * *

The physicians who brought this cause argued that the assessments against them are unconstitutional because they derive no benefit from it greater than does the general public. They note that they have been singled out to pay a large part of the cost while the general public pays nothing… The physicians argued that the link between the tax and its benefits was too tenuous to meet constitutional standards.

Even from the brief recitation above, the battle lines in the case are readily discernible: Dr. Coy was advancing the position that monetary assessments under the Plan deprived him of his due process and equal protection rights, under the law. Ultimately,
the Florida Supreme Court found that:          

[T]he rational basis test applies in the present case, as opposed to the strict-scrutiny standard, because physicians are not a ‘suspect’ class within the meaning of the equal protection provision of the Florida Constitution…. Applying this test to the facts at hand, we conclude that there is a rational basis for the statutory assessment of all physicians even though they do not practice obstetrics.

Although the court’s decision narrowly went against him, dissenting opinions contained within the 4-3 vote proved that Dr. Coy and the others had advanced a position of serious, even far-reaching, concern. For example, Justice Kogan (concurring in part, and dissenting in part) had this to say:

It is a truism that the power to tax is the power to destroy. While this phrase is so often repeated as to be cliche, I find nothing trite in the suggestion that the legislature can tax a person’s status without proper reasons. Such a precedent would make equal protection an illusory right. In the present case, the legislature has sought to tax primarily physicians to pay for insurance against certain birth-related injuries. This is little different from taxing only schoolteachers to pay for new educational facilities, or taxing only licensed psychologists to pay for public mental-health care, or taxing only policemen to pay for victims’ compensation programs.

When recently contacted by Lake Legal News at his SunLife medical offices in Fruitland Park, Florida, Dr. Coy easily recalled his “Supreme” battle for justice back in the 90s; in his view, the court’s decision rang extremely hollow. “When I read the scathing opinions of the minority Justices I felt gratified. When I looked for cogent dissent from the majority I was overwhelmed with grief,” he tells LLN.

Despite the fact that Dr. Coy’s words still (after all these years) convey a degree of lingering dissatisfaction with the adverse outcome, one can tell that the physician does not regret having waged a good fight. “I am not naïve now and I wasn’t naïve then,” he assures LLN. “I was blessed to carry the flag toward over-whelming enemy assault,” he proclaims. “The battle was lost, the state won. But as the defenders of the Alamo bought time for liberty against overwhelming odds, [so too] my presence at the Supreme Court of the State of Florida brought recognition that there are some who love freedom and are willing to take a stand,” he says with pride.

Even today, Dr. Coy argues that “the tyranny continues” in the form of what he calls an “illegal taxation of medical doctors through a private gimmick of ‘Maintenance of Certification’ and ‘Maintenance of Licensure’ — dictating who may continue to practice medicine and who cannot — while making a lot of money for the private company.”

______________________________

James Hope is a Florida Bar Board Certified Criminal Trial Lawyer who has been practicing criminal law in Tavares, Florida, since 1987. He has also been the Publisher and Executive Editor of Lake Legal News since 2009. He may be contacted at LakeLegalNews@gmail.com, or through his website at www.AttorneyJamesHope.com. [PHOTO CREDIT: Bonnie Whicher]

ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

S.W.A.T. HELPING S.W.A.T. — BRAZIL’S UNTOLD LAKE COUNTY CONNECTION

Next Post

GO ‘BEHIND THE SCENES’ OF OUR NEWLY REVAMPED WEBSITE

James Hope, J.D., Publisher & Executive Editor

Related Posts

SECRETS OF THE GAYLORD MANOR
From Our Archives

SECRETS OF THE GAYLORD MANOR

1 year ago
407
MEET A PROSECUTOR: JONATHAN OLSON, J.D.
From Our Archives

MEET A PROSECUTOR: JONATHAN OLSON, J.D.

1 year ago
493
S.W.A.T. HELPING S.W.A.T. — BRAZIL’S UNTOLD LAKE COUNTY CONNECTION
From Our Archives

S.W.A.T. HELPING S.W.A.T. — BRAZIL’S UNTOLD LAKE COUNTY CONNECTION

1 year ago
265
MEET A POLICE CHIEF: ADAM BOLTON
From Our Archives

MEET A POLICE CHIEF: ADAM BOLTON

1 year ago
236
HOW STRANGE IS CENTRAL FLORIDA? THINK “VAMPIRES, GATORS AND WACKOS”…
From Our Archives

HOW STRANGE IS CENTRAL FLORIDA? THINK “VAMPIRES, GATORS AND WACKOS”…

1 year ago
171
From Our Archives

MARK PALMER: CHANGE OF DIRECTION

1 year ago
171

WhatPeople are Watching

  • VIOLENT MAN BONDS OUT TO COMMIT ONE OF LAKE’S MOST HORRIFIC RECIDIVIST ATTACKS

    VIOLENT MAN BONDS OUT TO COMMIT ONE OF LAKE’S MOST HORRIFIC RECIDIVIST ATTACKS

    2483 shares
    Share 2483 Tweet 0
  • Jacksonville Man Drives 130 Miles For Mount Dora 11-Year-Old, Sneaks In Bedroom Window For Sex Acts On Video

    133 shares
    Share 133 Tweet 0
  • Lake County Jail To Release Nearly 50 Inmates Within The Next Several Hours

    7558 shares
    Share 7558 Tweet 0
  • Mystery Abounds In Developing Story As Body Is Found In Tavares Waterway Near Palm Gardens Marina

    1929 shares
    Share 1929 Tweet 0
  • Woman Rolls Stolen Vehicle After Chasing “Baby Daddy” Through Eustis — 14 Charges Pending

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

OurMost Recent in Time

Shots Fired In Leesburg McDonald’s Drive-Thru Across From Mall, Carnival

Shots Fired In Leesburg McDonald’s Drive-Thru Across From Mall, Carnival

January 26, 2021
3.3k
Arrest Warrant Executed — Clermont Man Arrested In Odd Case Of Exposure Of Sexual Organs

Arrest Warrant Executed — Clermont Man Arrested In Odd Case Of Exposure Of Sexual Organs

January 26, 2021
858
Access To Certain Lake County Public Records May Quicken, Following Fla. Supreme Court Rule Change

Access To Certain Lake County Public Records May Quicken, Following Fla. Supreme Court Rule Change

January 26, 2021
491
LCSO Seeking Suspect In Umatilla Shooting — Crimeline Callers May Be Eligible For Reward

LCSO Seeking Suspect In Umatilla Shooting — Crimeline Callers May Be Eligible For Reward

January 20, 2021
3.7k
Clermont Man Allegedly Tried To Break Child’s Arm Because Child Reached For Slice Of Pizza

Clermont Man Allegedly Tried To Break Child’s Arm Because Child Reached For Slice Of Pizza

January 19, 2021
1.3k
City Of Eustis To Launch Nationwide Search, Following Current Police Chief’s Resignation

City Of Eustis To Launch Nationwide Search, Following Current Police Chief’s Resignation

January 14, 2021
4.1k
State Announces It Will Not Be Able To Prosecute Lake County Armed Meth Trafficking Case

State Announces It Will Not Be Able To Prosecute Lake County Armed Meth Trafficking Case

January 26, 2021
4.8k
Groveland Man With Child Pornography On Phone Asks FDLE Agent  Whether He Can Call Mom, Return To Guatemala

Groveland Man With Child Pornography On Phone Asks FDLE Agent Whether He Can Call Mom, Return To Guatemala

January 25, 2021
3.3k
Lake Legal News

Lake Legal News

Published since 2009, Lake Legal News is a high-quality, glossy magazine blending current events with both topical and historical profiles of Lake County, Florida, attorneys, judges, police officers, elected officials, and residents. (Our website also offers breaking news and web exclusives.)

Learn how to Advertise with us here.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • An LLN Interview
  • Book Review
  • Civil & Criminal
  • From Our Archives
  • From Our Current Issue
  • Guest Author
  • Humor's Last Stand
  • LLN'S Hot Headlines
  • Odds & Ends
  • Of Interest to Lawyers
  • Of Interest to LLN
  • Our Magazine's Overflow
  • Preview Our Next Issue
  • Publisher's Personal Favorites
  • Take A Second Look:
  • Uncategorized

Take One Last Look

State Announces It Will Not Be Able To Prosecute Lake County Armed Meth Trafficking Case

State Announces It Will Not Be Able To Prosecute Lake County Armed Meth Trafficking Case

January 26, 2021
4.8k
Groveland Man With Child Pornography On Phone Asks FDLE Agent  Whether He Can Call Mom, Return To Guatemala

Groveland Man With Child Pornography On Phone Asks FDLE Agent Whether He Can Call Mom, Return To Guatemala

January 25, 2021
3.3k
LAKE JUVENILE’S PLOT TO KILL PARENTS FOILED

Active Sheriff’s Office Investigation Prompted By Shooting In Sorrento Liquor Store Parking Lot

January 20, 2021
1.5k
  • Home
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2009-2019 James Hope D/B/A Lake Legal News, located in Tavares, Florida.
Design by Artisan Internet Marketing, located in Mount Dora, Florida.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Favorite Topics
    • An LLN Interview
    • Publisher’s Personal Favorites
    • Odds & Ends
    • Of Interest to Lawyers
    • Civil & Criminal
    • From Our Archives
    • Of Interest to LLN
    • Humor’s Last Stand
    • Guest Author
    • Book Review
  • Online Only!
  • Read Our Magazines

© 2009-2019 James Hope D/B/A Lake Legal News, located in Tavares, Florida.
Design by Artisan Internet Marketing, located in Mount Dora, Florida.